What Food Writers, Critics, Editors, Bloggers & Chefs Want This Holiday Season (A Twitter-Curated Round-Up)

This morning I was going to write my 2010 Gift Guide–I did one last year–but then I thought: “Ya know, my colleagues David and Pim have already done such a good job with theirs, do I really have that much more to add?” Defeated, I turned to Twitter and, scrolling around, I had an idea. What if I polled all the food writers, critics, editors, bloggers and chefs that I follow on there as to what THEY want this holiday season? Wouldn’t that be interesting and more useful than anything I could come up with? So I asked a bunch of food folks, “What food-related gift did you put on your wish list this year?” Check out the responses below.

* * * * *

“The NOMA cookbook is definitely on my list.” – Chef Graham Elliot, Graham Elliot (Chicago.) (@grahamelliot)


[Photo credit, Eater.com]

“A new immersion blender. Mine has taken to sucking — and not in a good way.” – Joe Yonan, Washington Post food editor & author “Serve Yourself: Nightly Adventures in Cooking for One.” (@joeyonan)

“My food wish? The head of @rachael_ray served on a silver platter. That, or a kilo of tangerine zest.” – Ruth Bourdain, Twitter personality. (@RuthBourdain)


“I would like 2-pounds of pecans to replace the 2# bag that I had to throw away because they went bad. And a jar of molasses.” – David Lebovitz, blogger and author extraordinaire. (@davidlebovitz)

El Bulli resy so i can say i’ve been there half as many times as you!* otherwise, golden osetra caviar. the endanged stuff.” “$9,000 for 16 one ounce tins (http://bit.ly/icZT3R). plus ice cold bottle of vodka, and a russian-style man’s mink fur coat.” – Ryan Sutton, Bloomberg New York Restaurant Critic. (@qualityrye)

* Editor’s Note: I’ve only been there once!

Imperial Golden Osetra Caviar - 36 x 1oz jars.jpeg

“Probably won’t surprise you I’m a total Scrooge. Also have everything I need, thanks to super-generous consort.” – Regina Schrambling, Gastropoda.com. (@gastropoda)

“On my wish list: 18 copper canele molds. Unlikely Santa will bring them since they cost the earth. But a girl can dream.” – Dorie Greenspan, blogger and author “Around My French Table.” (@doriegreenspan)


“I already gifted it to myself. A countertop pasta extruder. Look out for some new great pastas at HEARTH.” – Chef Marco Canora, Hearth (New York City). (@MarcoCanora)

A huge tin drum of new olive oil, a Le Creuset Braiser & a new Benriner mandolin. But I’ll prolly get another cat tote bag.” – Pastry Chef Gina DePalma, Babbo (New York City) and Author of “Dolce Italiano.” (@ginadee)


“I need nothing. My wish is that lots of people get carbon-steel woks this holiday season and the wok revolution continues!” – Grace Young, Author “Stir-Frying to the Sky’s Edge.” (@stirfrygrace)

“A trip to Paris dammit!” – Chef Sara Jenkins, Porchetta & the new Porsena (New York City) (@porchettanyc)

“My wish list this year only has one thing: more time with my family and friends. oh, and world peace. i guess that’s two.” “But for everyone else: cookbooks this year! so many wonderful ones…” – Chef Daniel Patterson, Coi (San Francisco) (@dcpatterson)

Green Chartreuse, the expensive kind. And a case of Alecia’s Tomato Chutney from Bham.” – John T. Edge, writer and director of the Southern Foodways Alliance. (@johntedge)


“Hm. Well, if someone would take this deep-fryer off my hands, I’d be thankful.” “But seriously, the Noma cookbook. Just to drool over.” “And I wouldn’t turn down a nice bottle of scotch.” – Dan Saltzstein, editor/writer New York Times Travel Section. (@dansaltzstein)

“That super cool IKEA cookbook that’s not available in the U.S. (http://bit.ly/f0vVST). A long shot for sure!” – Chris McBride, Co-Founder Savory Cities. (@csmbride)


“What I am longing for is the LeCrueset cast iron “casserole dish” (blue please!) I have dutch oven, but want that one too.” – Kalyn, Kalyn’s Kitchen. (@kalynskitchen)

“I’m hoping someone adopts an olive tree in Italy for me this year. Olive oil from my tree for a year! http://bit.ly/16LFEF” – Kelsey Nixon, Host of “Kelsey’s Essentials” on Cooking Channel. (@KelseyNixon)


“Still holding out hope for the holy grail of Pyrex, the Moon Deco: http://bit.ly/fBUhoV and a @Sodastream.” “I know I can’t ask for All Clad Ps&Ps or THE KitchenAid mixer until I get married. (The main reason to get married, right?)” – Emily Farris, Author “Casserole Crazy.” (@eefarris)

“I want a new dining table.” – Monica Bhide, Author “Modern Spice.” (@mbhide)

“A 52 bottle wine fridge.” – Alice Feiring, Author “The Battle For Wine and Love.” (@alicefeiring)

Jeni’s Ice Cream, BLiS smoked sea salt, BLiS maple syrup (drool), a knife sharpening stone, and this: http://is.gd/ilrKQ” – Carol Blymire, Alinea at Home. (@CarolBlymire)


“All I want is a goodly supply of Blackberry Farm salami, Burger’s bacon, and a successful Meatopia. & A trip to Husk.” – Josh Ozersky, Ozersky.tv. (@ozerskytv)

“Asked for Share Our Strength donations instead of gifts. But I also want “Old Favorite Receipts,” a TX community cookbook.” – Lisa Fain, Homesick Texan. (@homesicktexan)

“It’s remarkably unsexy but a Rice Cooker with a congee setting, believe it or not! And what about you, mister?” – Matt Armendariz, Matt Bites. (@MattArmendariz)


“15 min in heaven at Cross Bros. Grocery – Ashland, VA.” “They have a souse section that shows up in my waking dreams. It’s my compensation for 12 hr drive to NC & enduring holidays.” – Kat Kinsman, Managing Editor CNN’s Eatocracy. (@kittenwithawhip)

“I fried my 4x kitchen timer the other day, so I will be putting a new one on my Santa list.” – Andrew Scrivani, New York Times Food Photographer and blogger. (@AndrewScrivani)

“A 5-quart @LodgeCastIron Dutch Oven. And several bags of Cha-Chas–these excellent dark chocolate cookies with cayenne.” – David Leite, Leite’s Culinaria. (@davidleite)


“The starter salt set from The Meadow. Just finished the book ‘Salted.'” – Garrett McCord, Vanilla Garlic. (@GarrettMcCord)

“Super fast IR/probe thermometer combo. Been wanting one.” – Pim, Chez Pim. (@chezpim)

“A gorgeous block of dried bonito and a kezuriki (shaver) to make dashi. Also a bottle of Punt e Mes.” – John Kessler, chief dining critic Atlanta Journal Constitution. (@jdkess)


“A bottle of vintage madeira and Darina Allen’s new book. Got both for bday!” – Leland Scruby, French Culinary Institute. (@LelandFCI)

“A KitchenAid mixer bowl with a handle. My inexpensive mixer came with a handle-less bowl and I always want to fix that.” – Megan Reardon, Not Martha. (@notmartha)

“The Frankie’s cookbook and the new NYT cookbook.” – Josh Friedland, The Food Section. (@thefoodsection)

“I asked Santa for the smoking gun from Williams-Sonoma, a Nitrous Canister for infusions AND a Vitamix Blender.” “But all I really want for Christmas is for Joseph Leonard to be open again!” – Sarah McSimmons, Food & Wine Magazine’s Home Cook Superstar and blogger. (@sarahmcsimmons)

The Smoking Gun™.jpeg

“I requested a Staub cocotte in aubergine! I’m giving microplane zesters as stocking stuffers.” – Tyla Fowler, A.G. cookbook intern & blogger. (@tylamfowler)

“Um, I don’t have a wishlist. But! If I did, it would include a metal bench scraper and a Cuisinart with a German plug.” – Luisa Weiss, The Wednesday Chef. (@wednesdaychef)

“I’m in the market for a coffee grinder i’ll use for spices and seeds. looking for second-hand options!” – Clotilde Dusoulier, Chocolate & Zucchini. (@clotildenet)

“For xmas: i want subscriptions to food mags. Love my blogs but must support the few remaining quality print publications.” – Doug Quint, Big Gay Ice Cream Truck. (@biggayicecream)

“Well, actually, I want @harold_mcgee’s new book!” “also, some great olive oil, really heavy baking sheets, and a personal oyster tour with @oysterwine!” – Shauna Ahern, Gluten-Free Girl. (@glutenfreegirl)

Salt pig.” – Joshua Hume, director of my Food2 videos and the Mario Batali iPhone app videos. (@joshuahume)


And, finally, an urgent e-mail from Zach Brooks of Midtown Lunch:

“sorry… i forgot to respond to you on twitter. is it too late?

because i’d really like somebody to send me a crack pie from Momofuku

Milk Bar… :-) ”

And that’s all she wrote, folks!

As for me, this holiday season, I put a request in for the two Piglet finalists, “Good to the Grain” & “Plenty.”

Thanks to all the writers, critics, editors, bloggers and chefs who responded to my question on Twitter. You’ve helped me create one pretty killer holiday shopping guide!

Let's dish!

Scroll to Top