Lucy’s Salty Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies + Momofuku Milk Bar Cookies

I care about you, readers, and I don’t want you to go through this weekend without cookies. Everyone deserves cookies, especially on the weekend.

The cookies I’m going to tell you about may already be familiar to you. The first, Lucy’s Salty Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies, were cookies I told you about in December. Remember I went to a cookie party? And how I was assigned Pfeffernussen? And how my Pfeffernussen were a bit tough and unwieldy, but how the best cookies at the party–salty chocolate peanut butter cookies–were so good I tracked down the recipe for you? Well now I’ve made those cookies myself and they are still mind-bogglingly good.

The recipe came courtesy of a person who knows every single person I know and yet I still haven’t met her. She’s friends with my friends Cara and Andrew (who brought the cookie to the party in the first place), she’s friends with my old friend Mark Blankenship of The Critical Condition, she’s friends with my friend Lauren Gunderson (you met Lauren here) and–get this–she shared a room with Craig just two weeks ago at Sundance. Her name’s Lucy Alibar and it is my mission to meet her one day soon. [Random fact: Lucy gave Craig a pineapple recently and I ate it. But I still haven’t met her.]

These cookies are so delightfully easy to put together, it’s the kind of recipe that it’d be worth adopting kids just to make it with them (you can give them back when you’re done). In a stand mixer, you just throw together 1 cup creamy peanut butter (use a commercial brand, “natural” peanut butter won’t work here), 1 cup dark brown sugar, 1/3 cup white sugar, 1 egg, 2 Tbs vanilla extract and a pinch of sea or kosher salt. You can add orange zest if you want, but I didn’t have any, so I left it out. You scoop the dough on to a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper (I used an ice cream scoop which made all the cookies uniform), lay a piece of bittersweet or milk chocolate on top (“don’t press down,” warns Lucy) and sprinkle everything with sea salt (I used coarse kosher salt and that worked fine) to taste (“don’t go overboard,” Lucy warns again). You bake for 10 to 12 minutes at 350 and you’re done. Let them rest for a minute then spatula them to a cookie sheet to cool.


So there are those cookies, which are a super cinch to make, and then there are these cookies, from Momofuku Milk Bar:


Diana brought these cookies as a special treat after we tested soup last week at The Great Soup Battle of 2010. To say that we devoured them would be a grand understatement. There was not a morsel, not a crumb to be found as we all shamelessly licked the table clean.

What made those cookies so good? Once again: salt. The best cookie (you can see it on the upper left), a chocolate compost cookie (which is trademarked, by the way), has as its ingredients: pretzels, potato chips, coffee, oats, butterscotch and chocolate chips. That’s right: potato chips and pretzels in a cookie. And, much like the salt sprinkled over the peanut butter cookies above, they cast a magical cookie spell. They’re insanely good.

As were the cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow cookies and the blueberry cream cookies (with dried blueberries and something called “milk crumbs”). But the lesson of this post is that salt, when baking, is your friend. And salty cookies are the way of the future. For further proof of this, try these Crispy Salted White Chocolate Oatmeal Cookies: another cookie option for the weekend.

Whichever cookie you decide to cookie this weekend: be brave, be bold, be salty. Just don’t tell Mayor Bloomberg.

4 thoughts on “Lucy’s Salty Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies + Momofuku Milk Bar Cookies”

  1. I just finished making these for a school bake-sale! They turned out delicious, but I have to admit, they were the flattest cookies I’ve ever made! How do I get them to be tall and structured like in the picture? I live in Minnesota, so I’m not sure if it’s an altitude issue (although I don’t see how it could be that, considering how simple the recipe and its ingredients are.) But they taste great! Any tips? Thanks for the recipe!

  2. The “salty peanut butter cookie” recipe above is simply incomplete. It IS MISSING FLOUR. Don’t follow the above recipe – you’ll only make a mess and waste good ingredients. The author should FIX THIS RECIPE so that others rea not disappointed

Let's dish!

Scroll to Top